[urazen]

Hi all,

My disco is in service now to fix the rattle packages. I just wanted to share the status with you guys.

1. Squeaks from tailgate
- They fixed twice, but it came back again after 2-3 months
- I think they will put more sponge or something in the gate, and I believe it will work eventually.
- If not, I think it should be a lemon.

2. B pillar ticking issue
- Mine didn't make B pillar noise for the first 4-5 months
- But it started to make the tickings from B pillar. Maybe temperature related?
- Honestly, I don't think they can fix it...

3. C pillar rattle issue (not sure)
- Mine started to make some plastic rattle sound from somewhere right rear seat.
- My wife tried to identify where it came from, and she believed it came from C pillar.
- I hope the engineers can identify the source at least.

4. Chirping sound from seat
- When I make hard 90 degree turn to left, it makes chirping sound from front passenger seat.
- I had the exact same issue in the rear seat, and they fixed it by replacing some parts (they ordered it from the factory)
- I think they can fix it.

I just made up my mind to fix these issues completely. Obviously, this is my 2nd-3rd time to address those issues. If they can't fix those time again, I will start to talk about lemon law with them.

Is there any hard timeline to apply lemon law? It's been about 8 months under my ownership. I hope I am not too late to escalate this issue. I could have put my car in the service center this spring, but I was just too busy...

 

[DrJJC]

I believe laws are different depending on your location. You may want to call 1800lemonlaw

 

[USER.000]

Or you can go here: http://www.dmv.org/automotive-law/lemon-law.php as Lemon Laws vary by state in the U.S.

 

[urazen]

Sorry for not mentioning my location. I am in CA.

 

[urazen]

Here is what DMV CA says:

----

In California, a vehicle is presumed to be a “lemon" by the Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act if, within 18 months of the vehicle's delivery to the buyer (or 18,000 miles on the odometer):

2 attempts or more have been made by the manufacturer to repair a warranty problem that could result in death or serious injury.

The manufacturer has attempted to repair the same warranty problem at least 4 times.

The car has been out of service for 30 days or more for repair to warranty problems.

Problems to the vehicle are not the result of abuse by the owner.

---

Though rattle would not result in death injury, it seems like attempting 4 times would be enough? What do you guys think?

 

[USER.000]

Further info:


California Lemon Law

If your new car is spending more time at the repair shop than it spends with you, you might have a lemon on your hands. Thankfully, the California lemon law is in place to protect consumers facing a sour deal.
Generally, the lemon law covers new vehicles with serious defects/malfunctions for a certain amount of time or mileage. If your vehicle can't be fixed after a reasonable number of repair attempts by the manufacturer or its authorized dealer, you'll likely be entitled to a replacement vehicle of equal value or a total refund.
On this page you'll find a general overview of California's lemon law and what to do if you find yourself with a defective car.
When Is a California Vehicle a "Lemon"?


In California, a vehicle is presumed to be a “lemon" by the Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act if, within 18 months of the vehicle's delivery to the buyer (or 18,000 miles on the odometer):

• 2 attempts or more have been made by the manufacturer to repair a warranty problem that could result in death or serious injury.
• The manufacturer has attempted to repair the same warranty problem at least 4 times.
• The car has been out of service for 30 days or more for repair to warranty problems.
• Problems to the vehicle are not the result of abuse by the owner.

If your car qualifies as a lemon, the manufacturer has the responsibility of either:

• Replacing your vehicle.
• Refunding you for the vehicle's purchase price.

If your manufacturer refuses or unreasonably delays doing either of the above, you can:

• Request arbitration to resolve the matter.
  OR
• Hire a lemon law attorney.

Start Keeping Records

While many car dealerships/manufacturers are great about helping you get a lemon repaired or replaced, don't count on them to keep track of everything related to your problems. Keep records of all the time you've lost from work, time the vehicle has been in the shop, and the exact nature of any problems.
Look over each service write-up when you take your car in. Unscrupulous repair people have been known to switch a problem diagnosis, or attempt to report an ongoing problem as new, in order to buy the dealership more time on a possible lemon.
What to Do if You Have a Lemon

If the dealer won't help you adequately, turn to the manufacturer. Take these steps:

1. Write a letter to the manufacturer asking it to buy back your car. This letter should be sent via certified mail, with a return receipt requested, to the address listed in your vehicle owner's manual.
2. If the manufacturer balks at repurchasing your vehicle, you have two options: Hire an attorney that specializes in Lemon Law, or ask the manufacturer if it has an arbitration program.
3. Check to see if the manufacturer offers an arbitration program by looking in your owner's manual, or by calling California's Bureau of Automotive Repair Hotline at (800) 952-5210. Request an application form and a copy of the manufacturer's arbitration program regulations.
4. If at all possible, attend the arbitration hearing in person. You can either accept or reject the findings of the arbitration panel. Should you decide to reject the offer, or if the panel votes against you, don't despair. If you are not satisfied with the results, you can always file a suit against the manufacturer through the courts.

Hiring a CA Lemon Law Attorney

A lemon law attorney knows the ins and outs of the CA lemon law and can help you manage your case and receive the highest amount possible.
Other benefits of letting an attorney handle your case include:

• Your lawyer knows your consumer rights.
• You may end up getting a resolution much quicker than attempting to deal with the issue yourself.
• You will have more negotiating power with an attorney at your side that knows the law.
• Your attorney can handle correspondence with your manufacturer so you can avoid making statements that could damage your case.

What Is Arbitration?

Before deciding to hire a lemon law attorney, you may wish to consider arbitration. In the process of arbitration, a neutral arbitrator helps resolve the dispute between you and your vehicle manufacturer.
You can seek arbitration if:

• You've already attempted to resolve the dispute with your manufacturer.
• The warranty problem has not been repaired and is substantially hampering the use or safety of your vehicle.
• The problem is covered by the original warranty.

Benefits

• Arbitration is free.
• The decision is not binding for the consumer in California.
• It does not require you to hire an attorney.

Potential Drawbacks

• You may end up receiving less than the California Lemon Law allows.
• You may get stuck in arbitration for long period of time.
• The rules of discovery are limited in arbitration, which means it can be harder for the consumer to prove his case through evidence.

 

[2Rovers_and_a_dog]

Discovery Sport Rattles

I too have rattles in my vehicle behind the driver seat... small metal chirping sound too. Some are just as loud as the music I listen to via the audio system. I have tracked some of these sounds to the rear seats and their head rests. Rear seats up, and I get the sounds. Rear seats folded down, and the sounds are gone or hugely reduced. And Yes Lemon Laws vary by state... and in Michigan it must be in the warranty period for the vehicle, and it depends upon whether the vehicle is leased or fully owned by the buyer (why = some people claim lemon law issues just to try get out of lease contract early). So yes... now that have learned more about where my rattles are coming from... it'll be another trip to the JLR dealer.

 

[DrJJC]

Excited to report my dealer was able to correct the rear seat noises and tailgate squeaks within the first 2 months of my ownership.

There are topix posts with LR ref numbers. Hope this is helpful and hopeful...

 

[urazen]

Thanks DrJJC.

Just wanted to give some update...

#1 and #4 seem to be gone now. But #2 and #3 are still happening. I don't understand how they confirmed that they fixed the issues. I will visit the service center again, and, from this time, I will explicitly hand over TOPIX number...